Mastodon
@Boston Celtics

Jayson Tatum vs. Jimmy Butler | Who would you take as your No. 1 star? | Celtics rematch Heat in ECF



Gary Washburn joins Arbella Early Edition with Trenni along with Tom Giles and Tom E. Curran to discuss Butler vs. Tatum.

CONNECT ➡️ Subscribe to our channel: https://www.youtube.com/@nbcsboston || Our website: https://www.nbcsports.com/boston/ || Follow us on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok @nbcsboston

🎧Listen to our podcasts:
🏀 Celtics Talk: https://link.chtbl.com/RJkwuSSg
🏈 Patriots Talk: https://link.chtbl.com/I4lb7Oey
🔗 Next Pats: https://link.chtbl.com/nextpatspod

The official YouTube page of NBC Sports Boston. Home of the Celtics, Patriots, Red Sox, and Bruins. We connect fans with the teams they love.

27 Comments

  1. butler played poorly vs the knicks and its being overlooked because of how bad randle and the knicks were

  2. The biggest difference in this series is going to be the supporting casts. If Tatum has a bad night the Cs have Smart, JB, White, and Brogdon to step up the offense. If Jimmy isn’t scoring then who do they turn to, Gabe Vincent, Max Struss? With Herro and Oladipo out it’ll be tough going for the Heat. Bam is going to have a HEALTHY Timelord to deal with this year and Big Al!

  3. JTs only issue has been consistency, but then again butler did not play great against the knicks. Both are great players in their own way. With that said id take JT for his 3-point shooting (when is good) and because of defense/rebound ability, not dragging down Jimmy he’s still a great player

  4. My annoyance of people' nonstop meat riding of Jimmy butler. We gonna act like he doesn't have a truckload of mid playoff performances. Go look at his Chicago years. He wasn't killing like this his one year in Minnesota or in Philly. They only talk about butler when he these great performances. When he's mid they just look over it and make excuses

  5. Jimmy over Tatum? Smoking crack the reason why he plays good in the playoffs is because he doesn’t play in the regular season hints the 8th seed

  6. Curren. Please continue the same energy of hate on Tatum throughout the rest of the playoffs. Butler is a dog and anyone would love to have him but Tatum finish 4th in the MVP race this year and made 1st team all NBA. For me it's not even close I'll take Tatum all day!

  7. The only thing Jimmy is better than Tatum is slashing to the rim, he gets alot of points because he knows how to draw fouls and get in the free throw line, if Tatum goes to the free throw line as much as all this NBA stars go, he would average 35 a game easily every game

  8. What the fuck is Tom Curran smoking? Lmfao. Jimmy Butler made the bubble Finals. Jimmy is 33yrs old & Tatum just turning 25 having accomplished just as much if not more than Jimmy Butler has. Jimmy Butler was putting up Grant Williams stats at Tatum’s age. People talk like Jimmy has multiple rings.😂 Tatum has never been that bad in the first half of games in the playoffs before, why is Curran acting like this is a common occurrence? Jimmy Butler had duds in the ECF last season too. And he didn’t even play great against the Knicks. Tatum is averaging 30/9/5 in the playoffs all while being the best scorer, rebounder, playmaker & best defensive player on his team. Curran is a dope.😂

  9. Apparently the number 1 seed 2022 Miami Heat had "no business" being on the floor with the number 2 seed celtics according to this dude

  10. The most ridiculous thing I've ever heard he's literally name playoff Jimmy because he's been inconsistent in the regular season. Jimmy the exact same thing Tatum does he give me 45 one game and 12 the next

  11. this inconsistent shit is such lazy analysis. you don't average 30 9 and 5 by being inconsistent. jayson has scored most points in the regular season and the most points by a player in the playoffs since he was drafted. you don't do that by being inconsistent. stop this shitty take.

  12. If you put butler’s mindset in Tatum’s body/skills that would be an unstoppable combination

  13. Is this a serious question? After just one great game? As a celtics fan I'll take Butler all day every day in the playoffs. Tatum doesn't have that killer MJ, Kobe or now Butler mentality. It was Mother's day so he balled out for his mom. Butler doesn't even let series go to 7. I bet Tatum doesn't have a game like this again this season. While Butler will and you can count on that. Replace Tatum with Butler last Finals and you don't got no unfinished business bs this year.

  14. So Jimmy is Jimmy without Herro. Heat have a couple guys. But if Jimmy goes down and can't do minutes, they're pretty much hit. The Celtics are loaded and improved from last season. Tatum has a bad game or Bown, Celtics are still coming at you. Butler averaged more minutes per game than Tatum or Brown. He has to play those minutes.

  15. People forget that last year horford had covid and rob Williams was coming off a injury and not 100%
    Celtics played game 3 without both of them and lost. It will be a completely different series with a healthy rob and Al

  16. Who is that guy talking about Boston and what’s his beef? Tf is he talking Scott everything he just said was gassed up I could t take anything he said seriously it sounded like a joke

  17. playoff jimmy and tatum are pretty neck n neck in my opinion, tatum has a higher ceiling while jimmy has a higher floor. i would give the advantage to tatum because jimmy is kinda banged up and tatum is a better overall defender, plus he's been getting a ton of rebounds as of late.

  18. Robert Williams is the KEY to winning the series. Bam is SCARED of Rob lurking help side behind him. Butler is SCARED of Rob lurking backside too.
    Gentlemen’s sweep without Tyler.

  19. Tom E. Thinks he so smart. He knows nothing about basketball. Why is he talking about basketball
    His thing is the new england patriots.
    So. Quiet Tom E

Write A Comment