Mastodon
@Atlanta Hawks

Paul Millsap was voted most underrated HawkOAT. Who is the most overrated Hawk of all time?



Paul Millsap was voted most underrated HawkOAT. Who is the most overrated Hawk of all time?

by SaltyTraeYoungStan

32 Comments

  1. TheHibernian

    Carmello Anthony.  Brought a lot of hype with him, but had terrible stats

  2. brohatmagandhy

    Jeff Teague. He was a good starter but not an all star and should have stepped up more in the playoffs

  3. atlbluedevil

    I think it’s Spud Webb. Not his fault or anything, but a lot of online discourse has him way way too high compared to how much he actually contributed

    Cool guy and fun as hell to watch highlights of, but I see his name online almost as much as Lou Hudson

  4. HankRHenry

    Dennis Schroder should be part of the conversation

  5. There aren’t too many overrated hawks. At least in my lifetime. I personally always disliked Josh smiths game tho

  6. LilGingii

    Lou will, such a liability on defense and if he wasn’t hot then he was useless

  7. NeedleworkerLanky591

    Josh Smith. Mainly because I was next to him at a urinal, looked up at him and said “You’re Josh Smith” and he replied “Naw man, that ain’t me.” Whatever, Josh. That was most certainly you.

  8. Captain_Ronnie

    Josh Smith and Joe Johnson for me. Iso Joe was good but never lived up to the contract and hype IMO.

  9. Jon_Koncak

    Jon Koncak was so overrated that he was being paid more than Jordan.

  10. Stephen_Hawkingbird

    A lot of folks are saying Josh Smith but quite frankly you need to be rated high to be ‘overrated’.. don’t think our boy was that. Haha. Agree with other guy, prolly Spud Webb

  11. Rasheed Wallace never much achieved anything near his regular stats in his time as a Hawk.

  12. KickedInTheDonuts

    By our own fans (myself included)… Cam Reddish

  13. Visionz-True

    millsap was underrated? everyone knew he was a beast

  14. Nah ur just wrong. He is on a great contract, and plays his role extremely well, competes hard.

  15. Dejounte Murray. The southside in me won’t allow me to say Josh Smith

  16. EchoedTruth

    Its absolutely Josh Smith.

    Wasted Potential is reserved for Reddish.

  17. pumpkindawg

    To me it’s Joe Johnson, and I’m a huge fan. He was awesome clearly but seven times voted to the all star team is kind of crazy in retrospect. That’s more than Kawhi and Jimmy Butler

Write A Comment