Mastodon
@Boston Celtics

Do all 5 Celtic players make the East All Star team for 2025 All Star weekend in San Francisco/The Bay?



Do you all think all 5 of our guys make it in as All Stars for the East especially for 2025 NBA All Star weekend in San Francisco/Bay Area?

by TerryG111

26 Comments

  1. neuroticsmurf

    KP definitely won’t make it. He’ll have missed half the season to that point.

  2. Ellswearth

    Even if they all played every single game, no.

  3. JB gonna get snubbed again somehow and transform into his unstoppable angry self šŸ˜‚

  4. sully9614

    Zero chance. Even if KP was healthy the record is four and the fourth came in on an injury replacement. I doubt the NBA would want 5 players from the same team to take up a third of an all star roster as well

    Edit: I forgot itā€™s 12 players not 15 but it only further validates the thought

  5. TatumBrownWhite

    The Jays will make it and Iā€™m going to hope that one of the consensus 6 guards misses enough time to where DWhite can snag a spot

  6. SongYoungbae

    If they’re undefeated until February, sure.

  7. CarBallAlex

    Weā€™ll have to consider they still do it by position

    So letā€™s look at the starting front court players in the East

    Giannis, Embiid, Tatum, Randle, Siakam, Banchero, Butler, Adebayo, Barnes, Brown can be classified as one

    And the guards

    Holiday, White, Brunson, Lillard, Mitchell, Haliburton, Maxey, Trae, LaMelo, Cade, LaVine

    The voters determine starters, and Tatum is more popular than everyone on the list other than Giannis and Embiid

    If every team gets 1 all star except really good teams (letā€™s assume Boston, Milwaukee, Philly and NY) then we can rule out one of Butler/Bam, probably Siakam, and itā€™s unlikely the middling teams will get the nod (LaMelo, Barnes, Trae, Cade, LaVine)

    Assuming no injuries, we can boil it down to probably

    Brunson, Giannis, Embiid, Tatum and one of Haliburton/Mitchell as starters

    Haliburton/Mitchell, Lillard, are the easy choices

    Forwards it should be much easier for Brown to make it if thereā€™s 3 names pulled from a likely list of 6 or 7.

    Plus the 2 wildcards

    Realistically, if the Celtics come out guns blazing and theyā€™re having a fantastic season, I can see Tatum being a lock, Brown being a likely reserve, and Jrue or White (not both) as a long shot for wildcard or injury replacement. But our guards would not be sure things like I think Tatum and Brown are.

    Nobody gets more than 3 all stars with so much talent across the league.

    Realistically,

    – Starters: Brunson, Haliburton, Tatum, Giannis, Embiid

    – Bench: Lillard, Mitchell, Brown, Banchero, Bam

    – Wildcards: Maxey, Butler

    – IR: Randle, Siakam, Trae, Jrue

    Feels pretty representative of the East All Stars

  8. Some of the homer takes on this sub are too much. 3rd options on a team rarely make an all star game, let alone 4th-5th options.

  9. imustachelemeaning

    everyone but JB. JT will make the 3rd team. KP will be injured.

  10. Orikshekor

    Too many good guards and KP probably wonā€™t play till after

  11. rocket_beer

    They wonā€™t allow it.

    But JB better be there

  12. Obvious-Ad11

    All aboard the hype train at ludicrous speed šŸ™„

  13. gyoyobw123

    Well there’s 0% chance KP makes it and Al obviously won’t make it either. So that alone eliminates this from happening.

  14. the_moosen

    We’ll get 2, and if we’re really lucky White will be the 3rd

  15. Beautiful_Article273

    If we are undefeated into all star then yes

  16. Jaded-Village-57

    Itā€™s a Fans thing so no. Tatum Holiday Maybe Brown.

  17. noBbatteries

    Lmao Zinger probably wonā€™t even play a game before the all-star break. Also no, we struggle to get 3 in last year even with being the best team in the league by a mile

    Questions/ posts like these make me full believer in the dead internet theory, as I canā€™t fathom a person asking this seriously

  18. Even if this were ā€œpossibleā€ in terms of what
    The league would want or allow. KP prob wonā€™t play enough to make it.

    Also, I want nothing to do with KP playing in the all star game. Chips or bust. No accolades

  19. Slavic_Dusa

    Everyone except KP deserves it. KP should be traded. He is just to injury prone.

Write A Comment