Dwight most accomplished player in franchise history.
Ok-Credit47
Shaq
StanVanGhandi
Gotta be Dwight.
Dwight isn’t the greatest player who ever played for the Magic, that is Shaq. But he is the greatest, most accomplished, Magic player ever.
KgMonstah
Serge Ibaka
itsameluigee
Just want to say if Gilbert Arenas doesn’t win most annoying then I question every other result
hitmandex
Tracy McGrady
AaronGOATdon
Best =/= most accomplished
Give me Shaq in his Magic prime over Dwight in his Magic prime
Bharper00
Dwight Howard by far
Shaq was amazing, same with a couple others but their time here wasn’t the same length or peak here.
-Buckaroo_Banzai-
Best in terms of skill during his time with the franchise? Penny, Shaq or T-Mac
Best in terms of most accomplished? Dwight
Best in terms of highest peak with the franchise ? Dwight since Shaq got most of his peak during the Lakers era and what he did during his Magic run was probably surpassed by Dwight.
Best as in most talented? Penny or T-Mac Fucking injuries man.
So overall answer: I’d give it to Mo Wagner.
ImpossibleStuff963
If we’re taking peak performance, regardless of longevity with Magic, it’s Shaq easy. He was a force like no other in the league at that time, and probably since, at that position.
mdesmond89
Dwight
faiitmatti
Tmac
misterdave75
You have 5 in the running. Shaq, Dwight, Penny, TMac and eventually Paolo. Shaq is the best historically. If you are asking, who was best in his time here, I’d lean Shaq. But if it’s, who had the best career, it would be Dwight.
colbycemer12
He won’t win but I want a vote on the board for Tracy McGrady. Team success obviously wasn’t there, but he was unquestionably elite all 4 years here. Unless Paolo makes a crazy leap, it’s gonna be a very very long time before we get a scorer of Tmac’s caliber.
cigamodnalro
DavieSmalls
T-Mac was the best player, Dwight close second but he took maybe the best team to the finals. I say do both 😂 Shaq n penny could be up there too but their reign was too short imo.
Clonth
Shaq is the best player to ever play for the Magic (Penny and TMac honorable mentions). Dwight is the most accomplished player (as far as accomplishments while on the team). I am hoping Paolo surpasses both, in both regards 🙂
BuckToothGirlLU
T-Mac is the most talented player by far. But…Shaq is probably the best.
DonutExotic2010
T-Mac
TyrusRaymond
0826man
Dwite
NByoungboss
Fug it, Paolo Banchero
WillDawson
Dwight Howard
CartographerFirst731
Dwight. He actually won a finals game in Orlando
slikk50
Penny was the best Magic player.
casebarlow
32
Bradtone737
Shaq
barberjo
Shaq
LeadDog44
The best player having ever played for the Magic was Shaquille O’Neal. But the best Magic player of all time is a tie between Dwight Howard and Tracy McGrady.
R_For_the_Win
There’s only 3 that have cracked any top 50 NBA players list: Shaq Ewing ‘Nique
DannerNet
It’s Shaq he was dominant here and is a consensus top 5 all time at his position
35 Comments
Dwight Howard
the year is 2028 and the answer is paolo
Mo Wagner
Dwight most accomplished player in franchise history.
Shaq
Gotta be Dwight.
Dwight isn’t the greatest player who ever played for the Magic, that is Shaq. But he is the greatest, most accomplished, Magic player ever.
Serge Ibaka
Just want to say if Gilbert Arenas doesn’t win most annoying then I question every other result
Tracy McGrady
Best =/= most accomplished
Give me Shaq in his Magic prime over Dwight in his Magic prime
Dwight Howard by far
Shaq was amazing, same with a couple others but their time here wasn’t the same length or peak here.
Best in terms of skill during his time with the franchise? Penny, Shaq or T-Mac
Best in terms of most accomplished? Dwight
Best in terms of highest peak with the franchise ? Dwight since Shaq got most of his peak during the Lakers era and what he did during his Magic run was probably surpassed by Dwight.
Best as in most talented? Penny or T-Mac
Fucking injuries man.
So overall answer: I’d give it to Mo Wagner.
If we’re taking peak performance, regardless of longevity with Magic, it’s Shaq easy. He was a force like no other in the league at that time, and probably since, at that position.
Dwight
Tmac
You have 5 in the running. Shaq, Dwight, Penny, TMac and eventually Paolo. Shaq is the best historically. If you are asking, who was best in his time here, I’d lean Shaq. But if it’s, who had the best career, it would be Dwight.
He won’t win but I want a vote on the board for Tracy McGrady. Team success obviously wasn’t there, but he was unquestionably elite all 4 years here. Unless Paolo makes a crazy leap, it’s gonna be a very very long time before we get a scorer of Tmac’s caliber.
T-Mac was the best player, Dwight close second but he took maybe the best team to the finals. I say do both 😂 Shaq n penny could be up there too but their reign was too short imo.
Shaq is the best player to ever play for the Magic (Penny and TMac honorable mentions). Dwight is the most accomplished player (as far as accomplishments while on the team). I am hoping Paolo surpasses both, in both regards 🙂
T-Mac is the most talented player by far. But…Shaq is probably the best.
T-Mac
Dwite
Fug it, Paolo Banchero
Dwight Howard
Dwight. He actually won a finals game in Orlando
Penny was the best Magic player.
32
Shaq
Shaq
The best player having ever played for the Magic was Shaquille O’Neal. But the best Magic player of all time is a tie between Dwight Howard and Tracy McGrady.
There’s only 3 that have cracked any top 50 NBA players list:
Shaq
Ewing
‘Nique
It’s Shaq he was dominant here and is a consensus top 5 all time at his position
Shaq was the best Magic player ever