I’d say Randle. He did more for this franchise than anyone else listed, and it’s not particularly close.
Urban_Introvert
Real answer is either IHart, Randle, or DiVo. But Toppin bugs me because he was showboating with his fastbreak dunks against us in the playoffs. Oakley would’ve sent him to the locker room for that disrespect.
Living_Internet_2970
Bogey and it’s not even close
confuddly
I wonder if you showed this to someone last year, if they could’ve guessed who we gotten in return. Assuming you told them IHart left in FA
PossibleYolo
Randle and Hartenstein. If Hartenstein didn’t leave I bet you Randle would still be here
No-Honeydew9129
IQ for me tbh
Scary-Web9739
Juju and iq
BuQuChi
I’m a say it now they gone, but I never like Obi or Grimes game. Wished them well, but they both are so stiff for their positions. Also IQ’s jump shot is ugly.
Savagevandal85
Rj
i-piss-excellence32
Randle for me. He came here when nobody wanted to just like melo and started this new era of Knicks.
I am happy for ihart but I also hate him and hope he plays terribly and loses in the first round every year. I went from okc being a team I really liked to hating them
press_Y
Randle and IQ. Idk why Obi and Grimes are even there
Kinda-Alive
Personally? Grimes😅
Glad_Confusion_6934
iHart
The_Royale_We
Only Randle
danbstonks
Quick🥲
Norby710
Still IQ.
ThrowSumDeesOnIt
Julius. Yeah, Julius. This man set the tone for the organization. Save for that one season (forgetting his first season even existed lol) he’s been a consummate leader, and all of his teammates have stated as much.
Odysseus_Lannister
Randle and quickley for me.
jbrunsonfan
What makes me feel good is that it was really none of their choices. They were all traded except for Hartenstein. And while the Knicks made the max offer they could, OKC offered like an extra $10M. And honestly fuck you people I’d be a Thunder fan for $10M. That’s not a choice lol.
Snapesunusedshampoo
NGL, this made me sad.
patrickthunnus
IH; he makes everyone around him better.
UonBarki
Thinking about this just makes me realize how actually fucking good our roster was.
nazrmo78
For me, it’s Randle. I feel like he started our path to relevancy and really expecting to win. We may not like what he did when it mattered most, I’m sure it kills him too. But you expected to win. And that’s what he brought to us. He was our first go-to scorer, and I appreciate him for everything. After that, it’s Quickley.
manfromfuture
Wasn’t Obi already gone?
Truck219
NGL, wasn’t expecting the iHart pic to gut punch the hardest
vimalmuru02
IHart cause we got something in return for everyone else
thedanbeforetime
iHart. we’re right there with boston if he doesn’t play himself off the damn team. love ju but i guess i mentally prepared myself for his exit since it’s been kinda obvious for a bit now that he wasn’t going to be part of the future here. Just left a little earlier than expected.
Fosheezy2
hartenstein, then divincenzo
TheSmith777
When Jules puts on the new uniform it’ll feel real. For now it pains me to see IHart in that jersey
mgillette416
I would’ve said we had a terrible year if there was this much turnover
vintageknicks
For me none really tbh .. if I had to pick one it would be Donte
-Hotel
Definitely Bogdonovich
moon_bounce_22
ihart
Big_Dumb_Himbo
IQ
richurr
IQ, I’ve never seen someone so happy to play for the Knicks.
38 Comments
I’d say Randle. He did more for this franchise than anyone else listed, and it’s not particularly close.
Real answer is either IHart, Randle, or DiVo. But Toppin bugs me because he was showboating with his fastbreak dunks against us in the playoffs. Oakley would’ve sent him to the locker room for that disrespect.
Bogey and it’s not even close
I wonder if you showed this to someone last year, if they could’ve guessed who we gotten in return. Assuming you told them IHart left in FA
Randle and Hartenstein. If Hartenstein didn’t leave I bet you Randle would still be here
IQ for me tbh
Juju and iq
I’m a say it now they gone, but I never like Obi or Grimes game. Wished them well, but they both are so stiff for their positions. Also IQ’s jump shot is ugly.
Rj
Randle for me. He came here when nobody wanted to just like melo and started this new era of Knicks.
I am happy for ihart but I also hate him and hope he plays terribly and loses in the first round every year. I went from okc being a team I really liked to hating them
Randle and IQ. Idk why Obi and Grimes are even there
Personally? Grimes😅
iHart
Only Randle
Quick🥲
Still IQ.
Julius. Yeah, Julius. This man set the tone for the organization. Save for that one season (forgetting his first season even existed lol) he’s been a consummate leader, and all of his teammates have stated as much.
Randle and quickley for me.
What makes me feel good is that it was really none of their choices. They were all traded except for Hartenstein. And while the Knicks made the max offer they could, OKC offered like an extra $10M. And honestly fuck you people I’d be a Thunder fan for $10M. That’s not a choice lol.
NGL, this made me sad.
IH; he makes everyone around him better.
Thinking about this just makes me realize how actually fucking good our roster was.
For me, it’s Randle. I feel like he started our path to relevancy and really expecting to win. We may not like what he did when it mattered most, I’m sure it kills him too. But you expected to win. And that’s what he brought to us. He was our first go-to scorer, and I appreciate him for everything. After that, it’s Quickley.
Wasn’t Obi already gone?
NGL, wasn’t expecting the iHart pic to gut punch the hardest
IHart cause we got something in return for everyone else
iHart. we’re right there with boston if he doesn’t play himself off the damn team. love ju but i guess i mentally prepared myself for his exit since it’s been kinda obvious for a bit now that he wasn’t going to be part of the future here. Just left a little earlier than expected.
hartenstein, then divincenzo
When Jules puts on the new uniform it’ll feel real. For now it pains me to see IHart in that jersey
I would’ve said we had a terrible year if there was this much turnover
For me none really tbh .. if I had to pick one it would be Donte
Definitely Bogdonovich
ihart
IQ
IQ, I’ve never seen someone so happy to play for the Knicks.
IHart and Devo for me.
I’ll always be a fan of IQ.
IQ and Donte.